Scale Breaking Points: Census Consensus

Hi! Happy New Year!

Two posts today! Woot! 

In my previous blog post I recommended we mandate in our next US Constitution upgrades be required as scale and time invalidate our rights. However, I only recommended a general solution. Here I recommend two specific solutions for assessing breaking points.

Allow Scale and Time Appeals

One way to assess breaking points is to allow a new kind of legal appeal or precedent of time and scale. In my previous blog post I lamented that the founders did not think to include an amendment that forbids waiving rights.

However, let us assume for the moment that we keep things the way they are. Assume people are allowed to enter into arbitration agreements in lieu of trial-by-jury. The breaking point could be assessed by allowing for a legal appeal by scale. If some contract or law includes waiving a right then the judgement can be appealed for reason of scale. If the arbitration were deemed a manifestation of scale or time then the appeal wins.

The legal quagmire that would ensue then would expose the breaking point, in this case courtrooms do not have enough capacity. The quagmire would be the motivation to amend the constitution.

The amendment to the US Constitution might go something like below.

Right to Scale Amendment

Any law suit is voided when rights are waived and waiving those rights are done so on a premise of cost, practicality, feasibility, time and other issues of scale.

Census Consensus

The right to scale mentioned above is kinda obvious. Any time we are waiving our rights this should be a big red light: amend the US Constitution.

The more subtle one is capturing attitude change due to time shift. Examples of attitude shifts are:
  1. 100% shift where trial-by-jury that is mostly snubbed by Americans today. 
  2. 50% shift where Americans are deeply divided on guns.
  3. New rights such as abortion where Americans have never spoken as a people.
How do we capture the breaking points of time and scale?

My solution is census consensus. First we need to upgrade the census to be real-time via electronic updates. Albeit the web, phone or other device people need to be counted in real-time. We should institute a new US Constitution requirement that a real-time census be allowed, warts and all.

I do not advocate direct democracy. However, that should not prevent our representatives from knowing without polling how Americans feel on the important rights issues, including new rights like abortion.

All of our rights should be subject to census consensus. Breaking points of scale and time can be assessed by a census consensus. Changes to public attitudes over time can be monitored directly and not by polling, but a real-time census. People being counted as part of a census should include their rights attitudes. As rights attitudes change then amendments to the US Constitution are mandated.

Census Consensus Amendment

The US Government will institute a real-time, electronic census that counts not only people but people's attitudes about rights. Any change of ten percent over ten years in rights attitudes mandates a US Constitutional amendment to reflect the attitude change.

No Fear

Every generation should be extremely comfortable amending the US Constitution as reflects that generation's attitudes.  For too long we have treated the US Constitution as sacred and something revered when it is far more important for every generation to own the US Constitution by amending it fearlessly to reflect the sensibilities of the day.

Well come! and Well met!















Comments

Post a Comment

Explore

You Need To Start Making Political Decisions

Image
Hi! Happy Wednesday! Yesterday Jimmy Carter was interviewed where in essence he was saying the US is no longer a Democracy, but an oligarchy. But that is actually being nice. It is corruption plain and simple. The US has become like Mexico, China and most other countries around the world. Corruption rules. I posted Carter's interview on Facebook yesterday and made two important arguments yesterday regarding Carter's observation: Root cause was scale. Our success has become our failure. Our success has been since WWI the US has become the richest country in the world, by orders of magnitude. In Silicon Valley we say that your success becomes your failure when something "goes viral", or the scale of growth quickly overwhelms either the company or the technology. Internet start ups fail because ten, twenty or even one-thousand times more web visits can bring down a site. Going viral means scale grows orders of magnitude too quickly to manage. This is ca
Read more

Love, Hard Work Book Draft: Introduction

Image
Love, Hard Work By Mybrid Wonderful A New Government (For Making New Governments) Irreni World Scale "Irreni World Scale means hard work. Hard work in the past meant physical labor, back breaking labor of long hours. Hard work today means brain labor of social skills, getting along with people productively." -Mybrid Wonderful, "Love, Hard Work - Introduction" "Don't Panic! Two-hundred-million world governments as proposed by Irreni and opposed to today's two-hundred world governments is not meant to happen over night, but rather over two-hundred years." -Mybrid Wonderful, "Love, Hard Work - Introduction" Welcome to Love, Hard Work! Introduction    Before we get started, duty demands I lay down a couple of things first. Irreni World Scale means hard work. Hard work in the past meant physical labor, back breaking labor of long hours. Hard work today means brain labor of social skills, getting along with people produ
Read more

Irreni Manages Bad Reasoning

Image
Bad Reasoning Bad reasoning. We all have it and do it. Some of us more than others. How many times have we heard the average person doesn't understand finances? And yet everyone is expected to have their retirement invested? What kind of mad world is this? We demand financial savvy where none exists? It is almost as if the system is rigged to rip us all off while telling us it is our fault and we buy it hook, line, and sinker? The sad fact is we do let them get away with it because we do think it is our fault. Irreni World Scale manages bad reasoning. Some people may naively think that ignorance of something like finances is the only cause. Not at all. I know people with degrees in Math who buy lottery tickets. When I ask them if they know they are just throwing away money they say yes. On a more personal level I know I should be exercising but I don't. I guess in some ways one could consider this bad decision making over bad reasoning because I know the right answe
Read more

No Secret Ballots, Public Voting

Image
Hi! Happy Saturday! Mmmm, the last Irreni blog post was about empowering the voting franchise by six-degrees of voting. Conversations equal consensus. Today I'm going to further expand that power of your vote with public voting. Information is power. Secret information is not power. Therefore, here now and forever more let all our votes cast be a matter of public record. The Vote Bank enables public voting. The Vote Bank will just be another app on your smart phone, your tablet or laptop. The Irreni World Scale solution for hosting the vote bank application is the Device of Life (DOL). The DOL is part smart-phone, part tablet. The DOL also has a protocol to access the Data Center on the Moon (DCOTM). When I talk to folks about abolishing private ballots the first objection is always on the order of persecution, "my boss might fire me." Bullies will be bullies, tyrants will be tyrants. If your boss or family member is going to persecute you because of your vot
Read more

The Amercian Anthem: Drawing Cartoons of Muhammed

Image
Hi! Happy Thursday! Irreni World Scale is about solutions, not political punditry. This solution presented is how to think about the current national turmoil about NFL players taking the knee during the playing of the national anthem. No one can disrespect anyone unless someone lets them. That's worth repeating: No one can disrespect anyone unless someone lets them. What is the correct morality with respect to this national outrage? What is good? The Good: No one can disrespect anyone unless someone lets them. The Evil: Anything else. When I was but a wee young lad I read a couple of books that brought this point home to me. One is a book by Piers Anthony, "Xanth",  Worthless people's opinions are worthless. -Piers Anthony, "Xanth" Another book with a positive spin on the same message is, "Dorsai!", by Gordon Dickinson. I respect those people's opinion whose opinion I respect. -Gordon Dickinson, "Dorsai!
Read more

Introduction to the book "Irreni World Scale"

Image
What is Irreni? Introduction to the book "Irreni World Scale" Irreni World Scale is a political, scientific laboratory for proving claims of politics. What is Irreni World Scale? Irreni World Scale is new kind of governing. Irreni World Scale has nothing in common with today's central governments of Democracy, Communism, Socialism, etc. As such Irreni World Scale is going to be strange to you. It is going to be weird. However, don't let that stop you from reading this book. Just take a few deep breathes when needed. Perhaps set the book down when things get too weird. Take as much time as you need to digest things, perhaps even taking days in between reading chapters. What we obtain too cheap we esteem too lightly. Obtaining the understanding in this book will not be cheap because the worth is a heavy esteem. Irreni World Scale is not a central government. Irreni World Scale is not a "rule of law" system. Irreni World Scale is a distributed system that uses
Read more

How To Scale, 101

Image
Hi! Happy Wednesday! Yesterday I blogged about applying Silicon Valley know-how to politics,  how under the covers of Irreni World Scale lie the principles Silicon Valley computing. Specifically I went on about the process of innovation being agile. Agile is defined to be a constant back-and-forth of top-down versus bottom-up design approaches called iterations. We can think of these top-down versus bottom up iterations as a revolution, a revolution of a wheel of design  where top and bottom of the wheel represent top-down vs. bottom-up design perspectives respectively. The new form of 21st Century revolution then is innovation brought on by each revolution of the design. I then made the statement that if there were only one thing to learn from Irreni World Scale it is this: that politics today needs new bottom-up systems for people to make decisions for themselves. Today, I'm going to change the one thing to learn from Irreni because there is an even more important fundament
Read more

The Intelligentsia Problem

Image
Hi! Happy Friday! The US and the World governments have an intelligentsia problem that has long been predicted so often that it is a trope in speculative science fiction. What has gotten lost amidst all of the demagoguery,  sensationalism, click-bait hate and histrionics that is Donald Trump has been Trump's complete and total incompetence. The odds of Trump succeeding at being President are exactly the same as the Infinite Monkey Theorem : The infinite monkey theorem states that a monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard for an infinite amount of time will almost surely type a given text, such as the complete works of William Shakespeare. Or, as John Oliver stated, the odds of Trump being successful are the same as a wombat successfully piloting an airplane. There is a lot of punditry that could splayed here. For example, people assume that a billionaire must be competent because a billionaire has a billion dollars. To which one can easily point to
Read more

Kavanaugh Debrief

Image
Kavanaugh Debrief Hi! Happy Tuesday! Who should you believe: Kavanaugh or Ford?  I don't know. One of my throw-away lines with respect to atheism is that religion is for people who cannot accept "I don't know" as an answer. I could brag that a religious inability to accept "I don't know" is due to a lack of humility. But that's not the case. The reason people cannot accept "I don't know" is that "I don't know" is unsatisfying, it doesn't satisfy to provide ground for traction to move forward in life. But that's not true. I don't know is an actionable and tractable answer, and so I give to you this debrief. For example, in science a hypothesis starts with "I don't know" as the only actionable answer to the initial hypothesis. The answer is only known after an experiment is run and results analyzed. So how is "I don't know" actionable with respect to Kavanaugh vs. Fo
Read more

High Tech Politics

Image
Hi! Happy Tuesday! Irreni World Scale is bursting with computer science principles to be applied to politics. Why? Because we humans know how to scale computers where both Google and Facebook have over one billion users today.  Irreni is a Silicon Valley political solution not just because of high tech advocacy such as The Data Center on the Moon or the Device of Life. Irreni is also a Silicon Valley political solution because it applies the design of scale we've learned how to practice in Silicon Valley where our politics today needs to scale but is sorely lacking in that department.  Yesterday I blogged about Greece and how Greece is a prime example of a failed state that didn't scale. Yesterday I offered analysis that failed states like Greece and Syria and Sudan are burgeoning in modern times because politics doesn't scale due to a lack of bottom up approach, a lack of people making decisions themselves. Today I'd like to take a further elaborate and take a mo
Read more