Lack of Qualty Criticism

Happy Saturday!

Lack of Quality Criticism



"We have heard the Rights of Man called a levelling system; but the only system to which the word levelling is truly applicable, is the hereditary monarchical system. It is a system of mental levelling. It indiscriminately admits every species of character to the same authority. Vice and virtue, ignorance and wisdom, in short, every quality, good or bad, is put on the same level. Kings succeed each other, not as rationals, but as animals. It signifies not what their mental or moral characters are. Can we then be surprised at the abject state of the human mind in monarchical countries, when the government itself is formed on such an abject levelling system?—It has no fixed character. To-day it is one thing; to-morrow it is something else. It changes with the temper of every succeeding individual, and is subject to all the varieties of each. It is government through the medium of passions and accidents. It appears under all the various characters of childhood, decrepitude, dotage, a thing at nurse, in leading-strings, or in crutches. It reverses the wholesome order of nature. It occasionally puts children over men, and the conceits of non-age over wisdom and experience. In short, we cannot conceive a more ridiculous figure of government, than hereditary succession, in all its cases, presents." - Thomas Paine

Pandemic help, for the day! is lack of quality criticism!

What? The Internet has unleashed every rat from every hole it seems. All three-hundred million Americans are getting in on the criticism game. Everyone is a critic now and the Internet is a cesspool of negativity. How can we suffer from a lack of criticism?

We suffer not from a lack of quantity, but quality. You want examples? How about books versus op/eds? The Federalists papers were originally published and  read in newspapers back in the 1780s. The Federalists papers became a book and are now considered legal references by the Supreme Court. Find me any such criticism today published in media as in depth as the Federalist Papers or of like quality. We lack quality of criticism, not quantity.

Specifically we lack the type of the criticism that The Federalist Papers themselves provided: system criticism. This is because criticism of a system is not clickbait, except when using epitaphs such as "socialism" or "fascism." The American system has failed because we lack ongoing quality system criticism as in depth as the Federalist Papers. Instead all we have today is clickbait criticism of people and systems.

The fourth estate, or journalism, was suppose to be that check in Democracy. The fourth estate was suppose to continuously refine the system of government to align the conditions of the day with ever necessary new government system requirements. What we have today instead is criticism only as sport where enduring ads are the price of admission to the arena.

Quality criticism doesn't sell. Period. Trump recommending  injections of disinfectant as a pandemic cure is not only peak Trump today, but also peak America. Trump the next day went on to say he was only being the court jester to his own court. Trump said he just wanted to see the media response the same as any jester plays to their king, except Trump is both jester and king. Peak America is being both jester and king because we want all the clickbait attention.

Trump recommending disinfectant injections is just the latest in Presidential buffoonery. The art at the top of today's post includes  an original quote by Thomas Paine that asserts one quality criticism of our American experiment called Democracy is that it safeguards against hereditary arbitrariness of character. History has shown it does not. Experiment failed. A couple of questions for your help today. First why isn't the media critically examining the American experiment itself when our is system under pressure in crisis? The same lack of criticism occurred under Bush. Bush was a buffoon that Congress would not hold to account. Further the media only bashed Bush, not the American system that allowed a Bush. There was no Harry Truman prosecuting war profiteering. Pelosi on day one in 2006 said she would not pursue impeachment of Bush, nor investigate any war crimes or war profiteering of any Bush administration official. Pelosi not holding a single Republican to account in 2006 meant 100% failure of checks and balances. The media not criticizing Pelosi for failing her responsibility meant Pelosi gave birth to Trump. A Republican party held to account in 2006 would not have credibility of buffoonery it has today. Both Pelosi and Trump are still in office. The experiment hypothesis of meritocracy of voting over hereditary chaos has proven false. Neither branch of government is checking the other regarding graft and corruption. The second question is why aren't we the people exploring options? Why is Irreni World Scale the only alternative in the world?

This previous paragraph seems odd because it is quality criticism of the system. It is not clickbait. It likely makes you uncomfortable and pushes you away from reading this blog because it exposes something you perhaps hold dear: American Democracy. This is the opposite of clickbait. It is tough love.

Democracy is dead and cannot fix itself because there exists no quality criticism of the system itself. We therefore need new government. Irreni World Scale is a new government but with a plan that takes two-hundred years. The two-hundred years are needed because first things first. First we have to change our culture, then our government. Cultural changes will span centuries. During this two-hundred years Irreni is designed to operate side-by-side with Democracy and gradually over time assimilate all governing functions until Democracy dissolves many generations from now. Want to know more?


Join an MGO today!

You can learn more about Irreni World Scale by visiting:

https://irreni.blogspot.com/p/join.html

Cheers!

Benefit of cooperation replaces rule of law!

Freethinkers unite!

Freedom!

Party On!

Let's get cracking!

Voluntarily Reject Demagoguery!

Politics as Science!

Demand Irreni World Scale!

Anti-theism is feminism!  

Think disruption!

Empathy for all!

Moral relativity: think it, breath it!

Prove it or lose it!

Conversations equal consensus! 

Welcome to the 21st century!

Scale your empathy, scale the world! 

Find your tribe!

Be sexy people!

The future is coming! 

Innovate at a rapid pace!

Slow speed ahead!

Well come! and well met!



 














Comments

Post a Comment

Explore

You Need To Start Making Political Decisions

Image
Hi! Happy Wednesday! Yesterday Jimmy Carter was interviewed where in essence he was saying the US is no longer a Democracy, but an oligarchy. But that is actually being nice. It is corruption plain and simple. The US has become like Mexico, China and most other countries around the world. Corruption rules. I posted Carter's interview on Facebook yesterday and made two important arguments yesterday regarding Carter's observation: Root cause was scale. Our success has become our failure. Our success has been since WWI the US has become the richest country in the world, by orders of magnitude. In Silicon Valley we say that your success becomes your failure when something "goes viral", or the scale of growth quickly overwhelms either the company or the technology. Internet start ups fail because ten, twenty or even one-thousand times more web visits can bring down a site. Going viral means scale grows orders of magnitude too quickly to manage. This is ca
Read more

Love, Hard Work Book Draft: Introduction

Image
Love, Hard Work By Mybrid Wonderful A New Government (For Making New Governments) Irreni World Scale "Irreni World Scale means hard work. Hard work in the past meant physical labor, back breaking labor of long hours. Hard work today means brain labor of social skills, getting along with people productively." -Mybrid Wonderful, "Love, Hard Work - Introduction" "Don't Panic! Two-hundred-million world governments as proposed by Irreni and opposed to today's two-hundred world governments is not meant to happen over night, but rather over two-hundred years." -Mybrid Wonderful, "Love, Hard Work - Introduction" Welcome to Love, Hard Work! Introduction    Before we get started, duty demands I lay down a couple of things first. Irreni World Scale means hard work. Hard work in the past meant physical labor, back breaking labor of long hours. Hard work today means brain labor of social skills, getting along with people produ
Read more

Irreni Manages Bad Reasoning

Image
Bad Reasoning Bad reasoning. We all have it and do it. Some of us more than others. How many times have we heard the average person doesn't understand finances? And yet everyone is expected to have their retirement invested? What kind of mad world is this? We demand financial savvy where none exists? It is almost as if the system is rigged to rip us all off while telling us it is our fault and we buy it hook, line, and sinker? The sad fact is we do let them get away with it because we do think it is our fault. Irreni World Scale manages bad reasoning. Some people may naively think that ignorance of something like finances is the only cause. Not at all. I know people with degrees in Math who buy lottery tickets. When I ask them if they know they are just throwing away money they say yes. On a more personal level I know I should be exercising but I don't. I guess in some ways one could consider this bad decision making over bad reasoning because I know the right answe
Read more

The Amercian Anthem: Drawing Cartoons of Muhammed

Image
Hi! Happy Thursday! Irreni World Scale is about solutions, not political punditry. This solution presented is how to think about the current national turmoil about NFL players taking the knee during the playing of the national anthem. No one can disrespect anyone unless someone lets them. That's worth repeating: No one can disrespect anyone unless someone lets them. What is the correct morality with respect to this national outrage? What is good? The Good: No one can disrespect anyone unless someone lets them. The Evil: Anything else. When I was but a wee young lad I read a couple of books that brought this point home to me. One is a book by Piers Anthony, "Xanth",  Worthless people's opinions are worthless. -Piers Anthony, "Xanth" Another book with a positive spin on the same message is, "Dorsai!", by Gordon Dickinson. I respect those people's opinion whose opinion I respect. -Gordon Dickinson, "Dorsai!
Read more

Introduction to the book "Irreni World Scale"

Image
What is Irreni? Introduction to the book "Irreni World Scale" Irreni World Scale is a political, scientific laboratory for proving claims of politics. What is Irreni World Scale? Irreni World Scale is new kind of governing. Irreni World Scale has nothing in common with today's central governments of Democracy, Communism, Socialism, etc. As such Irreni World Scale is going to be strange to you. It is going to be weird. However, don't let that stop you from reading this book. Just take a few deep breathes when needed. Perhaps set the book down when things get too weird. Take as much time as you need to digest things, perhaps even taking days in between reading chapters. What we obtain too cheap we esteem too lightly. Obtaining the understanding in this book will not be cheap because the worth is a heavy esteem. Irreni World Scale is not a central government. Irreni World Scale is not a "rule of law" system. Irreni World Scale is a distributed system that uses
Read more

Kavanaugh Debrief

Image
Kavanaugh Debrief Hi! Happy Tuesday! Who should you believe: Kavanaugh or Ford?  I don't know. One of my throw-away lines with respect to atheism is that religion is for people who cannot accept "I don't know" as an answer. I could brag that a religious inability to accept "I don't know" is due to a lack of humility. But that's not the case. The reason people cannot accept "I don't know" is that "I don't know" is unsatisfying, it doesn't satisfy to provide ground for traction to move forward in life. But that's not true. I don't know is an actionable and tractable answer, and so I give to you this debrief. For example, in science a hypothesis starts with "I don't know" as the only actionable answer to the initial hypothesis. The answer is only known after an experiment is run and results analyzed. So how is "I don't know" actionable with respect to Kavanaugh vs. Fo
Read more

Love, Hard Work Book Draft: Chapter 1

Image
Love Hard Work By Mybrid Wonderful A New Government (For Making New Governments) Irreni World Scale Welcome to Love, Hard Work! Introduction    Before we get started, duty demands I lay down a couple of things first. Irreni World Scale means hard work. Hard work in the past meant physical labor, back breaking labor of long hours. Hard work today means brain labor of social skills, getting along with people productively. Don't Panic! Two-hundred-million world governments proposed by Irreni as opposed to today's two-hundred world governments is not meant to happen over night, but rather over two-hundred years. Introduction: December 4, 2018 You ever wake up, roll over, look at the blue-glowing clock to ask yourself if it is time to start thinking? And in part do so by asking  yourself, "Do I rule the Universe today?" Over the many mornings of my fifty-six years I have devised many different methods for answering that question: do I
Read more

No Party, No Government

Image
Hi! Happy Thursday! <3 An excerpt from The Hitchhicker's guide to the Galaxy* Chapter 36           The flying saucer in which Ford Prefect had stowed away had stunned the world  [and] there marched from it, down the ramp, an immense silver robot, a hundred feet tall.      It held up a hand.      "I come in peace," it said, adding after a long moment of further grinding, "take me to your Lizard."      Ford Prefect, of course, had an explanation for this, as he sat with Arthur and watched the non-stop frenetic news reports on the television, none of which had anything to say other than to record that the thing had done this amount of damage which was valued at that amount of billions of pounds and had killed this totally other number of people, and then say it again, because the robot was doing nothing more than standing there, swaying very slightly, and emitting short incomprehensible error messages.      "It comes from a very ancient democr
Read more

Legalize Prostitution? We Are Not Computers.

Image
Hi! Happy Sunday! Should we legalize prostitution? Yes. And No. We are not computers. There has been news lately surrounding Amnesty International's proposed new platform to decriminalize prostitution.  Should we? From the linked article above: But equally, critics and anti-trafficking activists say decriminalisation fails to take into account backgrounds of economic deprivation, pimp coercion and the intrinsic link between prostitution and sex trafficking.  Let us look at the word 'intrinsic': " belonging to a thing by its very nature: " This is not mere word parsing. Dogma can be manufactured anywhere at any time. And given there is no single world-wide religion and further given topics such as prostitution, abortion, and climate change are world-wide then expect rapidly growing non-religious dogma in public opinion. What is going on here is an attempt by the author to make human trafficking and prostitution one-and-the-same and t
Read more

The Intelligentsia Problem

Image
Hi! Happy Friday! The US and the World governments have an intelligentsia problem that has long been predicted so often that it is a trope in speculative science fiction. What has gotten lost amidst all of the demagoguery,  sensationalism, click-bait hate and histrionics that is Donald Trump has been Trump's complete and total incompetence. The odds of Trump succeeding at being President are exactly the same as the Infinite Monkey Theorem : The infinite monkey theorem states that a monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard for an infinite amount of time will almost surely type a given text, such as the complete works of William Shakespeare. Or, as John Oliver stated, the odds of Trump being successful are the same as a wombat successfully piloting an airplane. There is a lot of punditry that could splayed here. For example, people assume that a billionaire must be competent because a billionaire has a billion dollars. To which one can easily point to
Read more